These guys laugh constantly while they talk, constantly. It is so irritating and insensitive. Not a lot of levity to this topic, act like an adult.

The rest of the time, book marked on each end with ads, never ending ads. Mind boggling.

The audio content is slightly good enough to keep listening to but the amount of ads are beyond frustrating. Why put out episodes that have 5 minutes of content that you have to skip through minutes before and after. Also the audio quality is not great. From the

I have subscribed to this podcast. It says subscriber edition when I listen, but I still get ads…lots of ads…the same ads over and over and over. Save your money!!!

I liked the in-depth discussion and breakdown. Where they lost me is where they made the claim BK just had to try and fit in. That in college he would have found "his people" if he just tried. They theorized if BK could have just tried to be more normal, and less socially awkward, he could have had a group of misfit friends like Sheldon from Big Bang. He was getting his doctorate...so he possibly already had 6yrs of college to "find his people". Dateline stated BK was diagnosed with ASD. His brain is wired differently-not good or bad-just differs from a neurotypical brain. We don't know if he received early interventional therapies or was diagnosed later in life. The hosts's statements demonstrated a huge lack of knowledge and empathy for neurodiverse people. To the point it discredited anything else they had opinions about. If BK did commit these crimes, he most likely has additional psychiatric diagnoses such as anti-social personality (ASPD), psychopathy and/or sociopathy. How these present in conjunction with ASD is an interesting thought. ASD is not linked to high diagnostic rates in murders. The later diagnoses are. So his social "awkwardness" could have been his ASD (his behavior at the pool party & his awkward hiking text). If he committed the crimes the lack of morals, violent fantasies, and disregard for human life is related to additional mental illness. I think it is too simple to say he was socially awkward and couldn't fit in, so he must be a murder. I would love to hear an in-depth discussion with a mental health expert weeding out what behaviors are related to ASD and what behaviors are found in ASPD. I worry that theories stating his social awkwardness (aka ASD symptoms) was an indication of his future crimes will lead to a collective fear-mongering towards neurodiverse people. As an aside, one podcast stated he had dissociative episodes a a child and discussed additional health issues. I really think this case will prove to be a fascinating clinical case study.

Seriously, an episode I just listened to had the exact se ad played over and over at the end for solid minutes. I've got half a mind that contact the companies being advertised and ask if they know their money is being wasted like this. There are random dings and pings throughout episodes, like they didn't even bother to silence their phones before recording. Amaturish, do better.

I’m obsessed with this show. I can’t get enough of it. I love hearing them discuss the case and talk through things I would’ve never thought of.

I am loving the clarity and clean breakdown of the case. Very few if any podcasts give this level of info and detail and still remain truthful. For those of you are still not understanding how marketing works, you have an option to fast-forward through the commercials -take it, if you are too cheap or unwilling or unable to buy into the actual program that removes all the ads.. none of you could do a better podcast, but all of you can be keyboard bullies on his sound? Petty.

This is such an impressive look at the crime and the players involved. Aside from the annoying attempt to tease you in the 2 minute podcasts that have 10 minutes of commercials, the facts are so compelling. And the longer episodes are crammed full of details. There is a great attempt to show the human aspects of this crime. The facts are explained with a nice sensitivity to the trauma that family on all sides of this murder went through, and will go through .

That’s it. Stop breathing into the mic so much… and repeating the same content in multiple podcast

10+ minutes of ads on a 20 minute podcast is insanity. I wouldn’t even love a good podcast following the Idaho college murders. This podcast could be great if it wasn’t for a ton of multiple podcasts that are only 10 mins long and not full of ads.

Love the podcasts but Tony please stop sniffling so close to the microphone.

Interesting opinion regarding how long the case is delayed. Why isn’t there a STOP by legal minds n commentaries and lawyers saying “defense get to work with real questions!” You brought up a good point that if there’s another person who committed this murder- why isn’t the case trying to fund the true murderer???? Tax money, facts, true murderer- judge n listeners n podcast narrators- send letters n good comments to the judge, prosecutor, to get the case done!!!

I'm pretty sure last month sometime this podcast turned to AI presented and the live podcaster and guests are no longer on the show. I'm not wading passed all of the commercials for this.

I don’t know who these new hosts are or why they got rid of the original host, but they are terrible. I can’t even listen to it. They sound so scripted and inauthentic. They can’t even say the victims’ names correctly. I literally cannot listen to this podcast anymore because they are so god awful. Please bring the original host back

My go-to podcast for BK trial updates. I love the honest conversations. Could be a bit more impartial but realistic on the situation.

The podcast is following a topic that many follow these days. Like many other things and specially true-crime podcast subjects, many people have some sort of opinion about people in the story. But this guy, the host, pew man! He is super unprofessional. He is does NOT know anything of journalism! He spends ranting and ranting and ranting about every minor development in the case that goes public or is being circulated and how awful it is for the main suspect. Sometime I think I’m listening to the gossiping of some teenager mean girls.

Horrible listening experience with constant ads. Don’t waste your time. This is hands down the most annoying podcast I’ve ever listened to simply because of the constant ads. I went into this podcast with high hopes, but the incessant interruptions for ads made it unbearable. Every few minutes, just as I was getting into the content, another ad would start, completely ruining the flow. It's frustrating and feels like the hosts care more about ad revenue than their listeners' experience. Save yourself the frustration and skip this one. There are plenty of other podcasts out there that respect their audience's time.

I have to admit that this podcast has interesting content and they release podcasts frequently. In the unpaid version, there are multiple ads at the beginning and end of each episode, some of which are only a few minutes long themselves. If you are trying to listen to a few episodes in a row, you will be absolutely barraged with ads, many of them are back to back repeats, without always having much actual podcast in between. In the paid version, you lose the ability to follow specific cases, and there is not a filter to single them out. You HAVE to go through every case they are covering to get to the ones you want. This is especially a pain when you are trying to stream one case at a time. I ended up dropping the paid after just a couple of months, because it was as frustrating as the ads in its own way. I haven’t found a better way to listen to them on other apps, so I’m just moving on. It’s a good show, so it’s a shame it’s so frustrating to listen to.

If you would lengthen the episodes to at least 30 to 45 minutes and use ads sparingly like other podcasters do you’d be a five star podcast. It’s just too annoying to listen to and it has the potential to be great. I hope you listen to what your listeners are saying because that is your audience.

This is an interesting case, but this podcast isn’t the way to follow it. It seems to be mostly snarky comments about how stupid they think Kohberger’s alibi is, and almost implying that defense counsel is stupid for offering it. Do they not know how criminal defense works? Do they think that lawyers suborn perjury by crafting stories for their client to follow? They seem to be a combination of ignorant and cynical. A more professional approach grounded in understanding of the system, and a more evenhanded coverage of the case as it progresses, would help quite a bit.

Great show but 3 minutes of ads before the show starts and 15 at the end! Come on Tony!!

Not for me. 75% ads / 25% content. Great if you like ads.

This is like 2 minutes of information and 10 minutes of ads. Unfollowing.

Don’t waste your time. 90% of the episodes are ads.

The amount of cussing is atrocious! Good grief! It’s so unnecessary! You rate your show as clean? Every other sentence you’re cussing! 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬

For a case this intricate there should be plenty of content for a longer show and with less ads.

The ridiculously short episodes aren’t worth the amount of ads you have to listen to.

About 70% of the episode is commercials. Can’t listen.

Have to fast forward through 5 mins of ads for 5 mins of content

Ridiculous.

The content you deliver is great and I usually listen to every episode but wish the format could be updated to not deliver multiple 20 min or less episodes (with 6 min of ads repeating over and over at the end). Please consider combining episodes into ONE longer episode. I will likely unsubscribe to not have this and the other shows you put out filling up my new episodes constantly. No reason to put out multiple episodes in one day - it makes it hard to listen to with the many ads and will lose subscribers.

The amounts of advertising ruins this podcast. I have never heard any podcast with more ads than content. I would think if you create a podcast, you would want it to be successful and something people ENJOY listening to. You have ruined the podcast with your hunger for ad money

Love this podcast but hate the ads.

If you look at the length of each episode and figure two minutes at the beginning and two at the end, for starters you can see for yourself. There is VERY little content to the episode. Not for me. They must think we’re stupid.

Great show with good content but the ads make it impossible

I really like the host and I like the speakers he brings on. He speaks very intelligently, and I really enjoy the podcast. But they’re just too short and the amount of ads is obscene. It’d be better to do one longer podcast then all these small podcasts.

this isn’t a podcast

This podcast publishes so many 5 minute excerpts each day that it makes it impossible to find other Idaho murders content. Very annoying and Apple should let users block annoying podcasts like this one.

From the start, the chipper ‘Murder in the morning’ jingle is just gross. This isn’t a sporting event. Also, a 12 minute episode is about 3 minutes of information and 9 minutes of ads. Interviews repeat constantly. I listened for a while, thinking that some of these problems would be resolved with time, but nothing has improved. There are better podcasts on this case, skip this one.

Every cent you made off of this will be weighed against your soul. If you had a modicum of shame you would run into the woods and never take off your ashes and sackcloth.

The defense’s job isn’t to prove innocence. Anne is doing her job and what is expected? For her to just let the prosecution break protocol because of the notoriety of this case? I tried to give this podcast a chance, felt like the prosecution lean was just imagined but listened on to hear confirmation bias in its finest. Then the lack of stars made sense.

Some of the episodes contain literally more ads than content. I ended up giving up on this podcast due to all the ad content - 6 minutes of ads in a 10 minute podcast? And the podcasts are so short. Some 4 minute ones actually contain 1 minute of content and the rest are ads.

Podcasts are too short

There are way too many ads and it seems like the discussions are about the same on several shows. Just tired of spending time listening to ads.

SOOOOO many Ads. The SAME ads will repeat 3-4x in a row and more than that in the same episode. I don’t even mind ads or skipping through but as soon as the ad ends and the same one starts again it is annoying! Then episodes are being released that are the same. When working/driving/excercising Ill have to stop and make sure I’m not on the same episode. Different episodes, but the same exact episode too. The content and coverage is great, all 5 minutes of it that is incorporated into the advertisement.

Tony b covers the cases I’m interested in like Lori Vallow, Adam Montgomery , Kouri Richens and Bryan Kohberger . I’ve tried them all but it’s the same on each. Ten minutes of content, fifteen minutes of ads.it’s impossible to listen and try to drive, jog, housework etc because I’m constantly skipping thru ads, a little content then ads on repeat for 15 minutes. I wish he would read his reviews and change it up. I wonder if his content behind the paywall is better but I won’t pay for the same garbage we get for free!

I listened to off-brand Lisa Kudrow and host Wolfman Drivetime Jack for a few minutes that I’ll never get back. The psychologist was offering analysis of the suspect, which is completely unprofessional… leading me to believe she wasn’t actually a professional as claimed. The Moscow case has attracted a bunch of greedy loons.

Keep your political views to yourself. Gross.

The guy who runs this podcast is so exploitive of the victims. The first episode is him laughing and joking with the cohost. Parents lost their children!! There are so many ads because this is how he’s making money. Do not listen, do not subscribe. Do not give him the fuel or encourage this kind of podcasting. He’s not an investigative journalist reporting on a crime that he knows a lot about. He mispronounces the name of the victims and the name of the town because he’s not from there. This is a money making venture for him. Please do not help him do that at the expense of the victims.