He’s so interesting and well informed. And a mensch I wonder why the sound is so poor. Especially with the music lover like David. It often sounds like he’s not in front of his mic and the worst is when you have Collins because it’s very difficult to understand anything they asking.

So I was purposely looking for negative comments on this podcast and to see why they were there… I saw one that stood out talking about how Phil and David have guests on there without explanation or introducing them or how they know certain celebrities and named dropping, but if you don’t fast-forward through any of the podcast minus the commercials, they clearly state in the beginning of the episode, their special guests, and how they are connected connected to that guest and why they are putting them on the show to be interviewed. I was a little confused, but then I realized who’s not understand. This has been fast forwarding the podcast. The show was great and they do eat lunch with people they enjoy having in their lives through connections or through work experience or somehow crossing paths at some point in their lives. It clearly stated everything is clear so if anybody else is a little confused please read this comment. By the way, I bet in Portland was doing his book tour and I had no idea who David is I just nonchalantly ask him if Phil could be on my podcast and I wish I would’ve stopped to talk to David Moore because his background is so interesting because I really love music and films.

What no I LOVE LUCY!! Enjoy the podcast and the guests you have are entertaining the banter between you with your great life experiences and of course the food and travel are definite highlights too

I really like Phil Rosenthal, which is why I wanted to try this podcast. The Jane Fonda episodes are good and a few others have been interesting, but overall it’s been difficult to enjoy. There is a lot of name dropping and references to people “in the biz” that makes everything difficult to make sense of. There’s not always a clear definition of why the guest is there. Sometimes guests are there promoting something, however I thought it was supposed to just conversation over lunch? Not many episodes introduce guests or at least give the listener any context as to who the person is. David wild seems like a nice guy to talk to, but the constant fan talk and references to a life knowing all kinds of Hollywood actors/musicians/executives is not something that is relatable as a “regular person”. It’s one of the most frustrating parts of the podcast. While I know that the podcast has an E - explicit rating, there are some triggering conversations that happen during interviews and NO WARNING of the subject matter that is discussed. Trigger warnings during the introduction of the podcast would be helpful for people who may be offended by certain trauma discussed. Phil is a food guy and I appreciate his Netflix show about connecting over food, but this podcast doesn’t help me feel connected to any of the guests.

I very much enjoy the podcast. It accompanies me on most of my walks and workouts. I do want to offer one piece of constructive criticism for David….try to minimize using “like” in your questions and when relating stories. It makes my toes curl, particularly given the frequency with which you use the word. For me, it’s very distracting and takes away from the substance and integrity of what you’re saying.

My goodness, I’m not sure if you’ll find a pair of more charming, humble gents in Hollywood. These two have some amazing guests they genuinely seem to have real life friendships with. You can feel the high level of integrity of character as they schmooze & lunch while giving us the best Hollywood stories. What a fun fast pod to listen to. Always leaves me smiling. Good vibes only.

I couldn’t finish the Andy Kindler ‘cast; stopped approximately 4 minutes in.

I listen to you guys on the way to work. A great, positive start to my day. I hope someday you seek out June from Delish magazine. She did a series called Budget Eats during the pandemic. I think she’d make a great guest on your show.

David seems to have had quite the career that’s for certain. I don’t need to know about this fact every episode nor have him step on guest’s answers/not let them answer or just fumble and stumble around. Season 1 I was able to handle this but no mas. Sorry but have to say it as this is an annoyance every episode.

This episode spans a timeline full of life and love. Yes everybody loves Phil but with David we get so naked. Not that we want to feed a naked Phil, mind you. Thank you, guys. These two amazingly talented writers bring their craft to the table where we meet Donny Osmond. The idea is furtherest from in considering how these two would celebrate the 100 milestone. And yet this concept sums up this podcast. The sheer charm that these three share in hearing Donny’s stories is truly special. You gotta have a listen.

I am looking forward to downloading some more episodes!

I was totally tuned into part 1 of your Donny Osmond podcast. I loved it. The memories you brought back were fantastic. He’s had an amazing life.

The best lunch that you will ever have.

Loved the interaction between Lily and Phil. So heart warming to listen to there interactions and feel the love and joy between them. Lily is so funny. Hope she comes back for an encore!

Always want to hear updates on what Jane is doing politically. David talks too much, taking away time from the guests. We want to hear the guests! Lately the podcasts are more on David and his career and circle which is turning me off. Want more Phil and his circle. If David has so much to talk about Rolling Stone and his work, then start his own podcast

Great shows! Thank you.

This is a great podcast and Phil is gracious host, however David Wild talks about himself too much taking away precious time with the guests.

I love love LOVE this podcast! I always love Phil and wish that you would put this on YouTube to watch! I want to watch everyone zabble and chat so I can actually feel like I’m part of the conversation! PLEASE START RECORDING THEM AND PUT IT ON YOUTUBE!!

Please let your guests talk. David Wild at times talks for 3-6 minutes nonstop (literally timed it) without stopping. So frustrating. He has good stories but you don’t have to share them at this length.

Phil is outstanding. Charming, deferential and obviously trying to make every guest seem their best. But literally every time David opens his mouth, it starts with a name drop. It’s a distracting turnoff and I find I turn off early.

If these guys were as funny as they think they are it would be hilarious. The food hook is unnecessary, you have great guests but talking with your lip smacking mouth full is unnerving for me.

I retired recently and when people asked if I had any plans for retirement, I would joke that I was hoping to finally listen to all of the podcasts on my phone. Naked Lunch has been the perfect companion for my morning walks (new habit) and often gets me to walk another lap so I can finish the episode I’m listening to. Thanks! ❤️

I mean, Stevie got most of the air time but I love Maureen, and please do have her on separately! Thank you for sharing this really good chunk of time with them with us.

I overall enjoy this show. I will admit that a came and am here for Phil, who I adore. They’re slate of guests has been pretty good, but as a younger person, I might not know some of them which is ok, My issue with the show is that sometimes it can get overwhelming taken by David. I admit that David seems an interesting person and has some great stories, but they usually run too long and leave little space for the guests to talk.

I appreciated Phil and David’s friendly conversational interview approach, as they explored Joe’s guitar playing origins from age 4 to blues rock stardom. Their genuine interest and questions gave Joe the opportunity to share what it’s like to have a lifelong singular focus - interesting and inspiring!

I heard the Gilbert one and Paul Rubin one and going to hear the other’s so far great show

Us Gilbert Gottfried Amazing Colossal Podcast devotees sure miss Frank. David and Phil, you are a great legacy to that podcast and I look forward to hearing you both each week as much as I did Gilbert and Frank. It was a pleasure to hear, what could easily be, the three most decent men in show business all on one episode. Keep up the great work!

The interview with Frank Santopadre was enlightening. I listened to almost all for the Gilbert Gottfried podcast episodes and this interview explains a lot about the podcast. It was what I expected, Frank held the show together and Gilbert was changing the flow of the interviews with a segue that was unrelated. This is one of the best episodes if you’re a fan of Gilbert. Thanks for doing it!

Phil and David, deliver another great podcast with their guest Wendy Malick! Such wonderful stories Wendy told and it’s interesting to me to hear about how celebrities know and work with each other. Now I have to find a copy of Jewtopia and watch Phil and Wendy as Mr. and Mrs. Rabbi! Another fantastic show gentlemen! P.S. I would love to see Patty Heaton and Monica on the podcast talking about their Raymond days together. My husband and I have recently started watching reruns of Raymond and Monica is SO great in her part and Patty too! I think their comedy chops don’t get enough recognition so would love for them to have the opportunity to remind people what funny ladies they both are!

Food, great easy conversations and you both make the show fun, funny and entertaining! I learn so much about topics you bring up…..I’m an 80s music fan, but amazed at the knowledge of music history! Phil, would have enjoyed the opportunity to meet you, I understand your in Lenox Massachusetts right now 8/23/23–at Canyon Ranch. I live in a neighboring town. Unfortunately not offered to anyone outside of Ranch guests but I sure tried! Enjoy the Berkshires! Has always been my home. Tanglewood is wonderful this time of year …. Patty Carpenter

This is a terrific podcast with great guests!

I do enjoy listening to artists who have what appears to be and I trust truly is a good hold on life and love. Shaun is a good ‘un.

So glad to hear from my Teen Idol again! The excitement is back and looking forward to More shows and stories! Thank you for having him on your show!

Loved! Loved! Loved the Shaun Cassidy podcast! I’ve seen Shaun in concert 10 times now and can’t wait to see him again. I enjoyed hearing all his stories about his life. Thanks for a great interview!!!

I love Phil & David - would love more shows with just them - and MONICA! More Monica!

Not sure which host, but in J Bateman episode they kept interrupting her to a degree I found off putting and distracting. Maybe just this one and may give another try. Otherwise not bad

But apparently based on all these comments, I’m in the minority. It’s the human element folks ! The described interactions make these famous or maybe sometimes semi famous guests etc. seem relatable. Plus I will admit a guilty pleasure in hearing David keep apologizing for ir. Phil’s good too.

I love the friendly combo of Phil’s goofiness & David’s enthusiasm :) It’s fun to meet people in their informal talk & eat format. Interjecting their own stories of Hollywood & Rock Stars that are so personal & Entertaining!

I straight up love Phil and have seen all the episodes of his food shows, including the season on PBS. David Wild is not a great co-host, however. In love with the sound of his own voice and always has to mention his wife. I’m shocked you are married too, David, but it gets really old. The choices of guests and topics is wonderful, so will keep listening. Let the guest of the week speak, this is why you have them on!

If you were born in the 60s and 70s these are your guys

Love hearing Phil and David talk to all these people in a common conversation.

I love this podcast, but when David is in “fanboy” mode, your guests fade into the background and he talks ad nauseum. There needs to be a balance of sharing stories and experiences in the interview; I didn’t subscribe for a 60-minute monologue. Perhaps re-listen to your episode with Elaine May; that was a fantastic one because we got to hear her stories and bits of her classic skits with Mike Nichols!

Phil stop interrupting with all the “yes”’s; it seems like you are rushing the talker and can’t wait to interject your thoughts. Relax a little.

I got into this podcast because I adore Phil’s show on Netflix and rave about it to anyone who will listen. I’m now getting that way about this podcast. Love love love!

Great guests! Love experiencing a new side of Phil. David has toooooo many stories he’s determined to tell to be a co-host. He hijacks guests’ stories and episodes often end knowing as much, or more, about David than the guest. (Similar to trying to connect with people by “me too-ing” instead of listening and asking thoughtful questions.) I’ve just listened to a fifth episode and am giving up.

Fun podcast that shows more to Phil than just as a food fanatic. Love the stories from his show-biz career.

I'm a podcast newbie and I love Naked Lunch, however, while listening to Pamela Adlon story about Redd Fox, she was interrupted by David’s story. Pamela never finished story and they went on to other subjects. They did circle back to Redd Fox at the end but by then the story had lost its steam.

I love this podcast and love Phil! His co host has a lot to be desired. I will continue to listen because I enjoyed his show on Netflix and hopefully it will return.

“Everybody Loves Raymond” is one of my all-time favorites and I love being able to hear the other side of Phil. I’m a huge fan and love that all the conversations are stripped down, like you’re hanging out with Phil and his friends.

I’ll admit to being a Phil-fanboy. From Raymond to his appearances on Curb to Somebody Feed, I love Phil. And I really like Naked Lunch. And I hesitate writing this fearing I’ll hurt some feelings but David has to go. His continual sycophantic speech to the guests and his meaningless long windups to ask a question takes so much away from the organic conversation that happens. I long for one episode when he doesn’t desperately namedrop Rolling Stone. This show would be better without a sidekick. Or at least someone more tolerable. Maybe Monica.